📱 Download the only app with the macros of over 35,000 restaurant menus.
Tally's Tap & Eatery
Nutrition Facts & Calorie Information
S31W24661 W Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189
- Paw16" Super Supreme Pizza
Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, black olive and mushroom
12" Super Supreme Pizza
Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, black olive and mushroom
16" Bruschetta Chicken Pizza
Garlic, pizza sauce, fresh bruschetta, portabella mushroom, fresh provolone and parmesan, topped with balsamic drizzle
Want 35,000 menus in your pocket?
Download the MacrosMap app to get the macros for this menu and over 35,000 other restaurant menus.
16 Wings
Jumbo crispy chicken wings with your choice of two sauces
24 Wings
Jumbo crispy chicken wings with your choice of three sauces
12" Cheese Pizza
Served the way you like it! Topped with fresh provolone and all our fresh toppings!
16" BBQ Chicken Pizza
Memphis sweet BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, cheese, red onion, pineapple, and cilantro
12" Crab Rangoon Pizza
Buttery cream cheese sauce, cheese, crab, and green onion drizzled with sweet chili and topped with wonton strips
24 Boneless Wings
Lightly breaded, all white meat bonless wings in three sauces
Spicy Bleu Smash Burger
Double smash burger, with melted bleu cheese, bacon, avocado, lettuce and sriracha mayo, served on a brioche bun, with your choice of side
Wisco Burger
Topped with American, Swiss, cheddar and bacon, served on parmesan grilled Texas toast
Deluxe 1/2 LB Burger
Served on a pretzel bun with your choice of cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion
Original 1 LB Tallinger Burger
Topped with American cheese, served with a mound of our famous haystack onion rings as your side
Eat out, locked in.
Download the MacrosMap app to get the macros for this menu and over 35,000 other restaurant menus.
Download MacrosMap →12" Bruschetta Chicken Pizza
Garlic, pizza sauce, fresh bruschetta, portabella mushroom, fresh provolone and parmesan, topped with balsamic drizzle
12" BBQ Chicken Pizza
Memphis sweet BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, cheese, red onion, pineapple and cilantro
Small 1/2 LB Tallinger Burger
Topped with American cheese, served with a mound of our famous haystack onion rings as your side
16 Boneless Wings
Lightly breaded, all white meat bonless wings in two sauces
Cheese Curds
White cheddar cheese in a light batter, served with ranch
Pistacio Pesto Pizza
12” rustic pizza crust based with olive oil and pesto, topped with mozzarella cheese, mortadella, fresh burrata and sprinkled with crushed pistacios
Philly Cheesesteak
Thinly sliced prime rib, provolone, grilled onion and green pepper, topped with garlic mayo, served on French bread
Loaded Mushroom Swiss
Topped with Swiss, bacon, grilled portabella mushrooms and garlic mayo
Chicken Tenders
All white meat tenders served with Tally fries, coleslaw and your favorite dipping sauce
Sour Cream Tally Chips
Full order of homemade sour cream Tally Chips
Cuban Sandwich
Pulled pork, ham, Swiss, pickles, and brown mustard, served on French bread
Beer Cheese Tally Fries
with bacon
Cobb Salad
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, tomato, red onion, red pepper, hard boiled egg, cheddar and bleu cheese crumbles, served with garlic bread and your choice of dessing
8 Wings
Jumbo crispy chicken wings with your choice of one sauce
ALOHA BURGER
Served on a Kings Hawaiian bun, with a grilled pineapple ring, cheese, guac and shredded lettuce
Queso Blanco Burger
Topped with pepper jack cheese, cheese sauce, and pico de gallo, jalapeños and avocado
Beer Cheese Fries with Bacon
Tally fries topped with melted cheddar cheese, smoothered in beer cheese and bacon
Korean Beef Tacos
Three flour tortillas filled with braised short rib, pickled cabbage and carrot, topped with chipotle sour cream
Mama Tals Salad
Mixed greens, grilled or crispy chicken, bacon, tomato, cheddar and avocado, served with garlic bread and your choice of honey mustard or sweet chili
Beer Battered Shrimp
Lightly beer battered shrimp, Tally fries and coleslaw, served with lemon and cocktail sauce
Pork Carnitas Nachos
Pork carnita, provolone and monterey jack sauce, Pico de Gallo, over homemade tortilla chips, topped with guacamole and drizzed wih jalapaeno cilanto sauce
Quesadilla
Flour Tortilla stuffed with cheese and Pico de Gallo, served with chips, salsa and sour cream
Buffalo Chicken Pretzel
Homemade buffalo chicken dip stuffed into our giant pretzel, served with bleu cheese and ranch
Supreme Nachos
Tortilla chips piled with beef, tomato, green onion, black olive, and cheese, served with sour cream and salsa
Prime Rib Sandwich
Shaved prime rib, sautéed onions and mushrooms, served on French bread with horsey sauce and a side of au jus
Al Capone Sandwich
This Italian speciality patty made by our neighbors has a serious reputation. It comes topped with sauteed onion, green and red pepper on a garlic brioche bun, served with a side of marinara sauce
Bruschetta Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken smothered with provolone, topped with bruschetta, parmesan and balsalmic glaze, served on toasted French bread
The Gobbler
Hand carved turkey breast and gravy, served on a brioche bun, garnished with cranberry sauce, and your choice of side
Taco Salad
Tortilla shell filled with romaine, taco meat, tomato, green onion, black olive and cheddar cheese. Served with sour cream and salsa or avocado poblano ranch. Sub verde chicken or pork carnita Add jalapeno, avodcado or guac
Aunite Tals Salad
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, bacon, feta, dried cranberries, topped with green apples and candied pecans, served with honey mustard and garlic bread
Italian Beef Sandwich
Homemade here at Tally's and topped with provolone, served on French bread with a side of au jus
Not so Nashville Chicken Sandwich 2.0
Crispy chicken tossed in hot honey sauce,cheddar cheese, fried onions and pickles, served on a Kings Hawaiian bun.
Tally's Signature Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken, swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato, raw onion, and Signature sauce served on a brioche bun
1/2 Portion Nachos
Half size - Tortilla chips piled with beef, tomato, green onion, black olive and cheese, served with sour cream and salsa
Steak BLT Salad
Bistro steak cooked to your liking, on a bed of spring mix with cherry tomatoes, bacon, red onion and garlic bread, served with your choice of dressing
Reuben Rolls
Four hand wrapped wontons filled with corned beef, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, served with thousand island
Sweet Chili Shrimp
Beer battered shrimp tossed in sweet chili sauce, topped with green onion. Sub Mango Habanero sauce
BBQ-Bacon Jalapeño
Memphis sweet BBQ sauce, bacon, jalapeño and pepper jack
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, mild saouce, bacon, tomato, cheddar and avocado, served with garlic bread and your choice of dressing
Chicken Wrap
Grilled or crispy chicken, cheddar, bacon, romaine, tomato and your choice of wing sauce in a flour tortilla
Reuben
Corned beef served on grilled marble rye with Swiss, sauerkraut and a side of thousand island
Garlic Parmesan Fries
Full order of garlic parmesan Tally fries
Build Your Own Burger
1/2 LB Burger, or change your protein, then add more toppings for an additional charge!
Chips
Full order of homemade chips
Chips-N-Guacamole
Fresh tortilla chips with homemade guacamole
Chips-N-Cheese
Fresh tortilla chips with monteray jack cheese sauce
Giant Pretzel
Served with homemade beer cheese and honey mustard
Giant Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie
Giant hot chocolate chip cookie topped with chocolate sauce and whipped cream
Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine, house made croutons and grilled OR crispy chicken in a creamy Caesar dessing, served with garlic bread
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled or crispy chicken, romaine and parmesean with our creamy Caesar in a flour tortilla
Pizza Pretzel
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage and cheese served with marinara and garlic butter
Dill Cheese Curds
White dill cheddar cheese in a light batter, served with ranch
Spinach Artichoke Pretzel
Served with Ranch & Garlic Butter
Jerk Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken, pineapple salsa, cabbage, provolone and Jamaican Jerk sauce
Butterfly Shrimp
Breaded butterfly shrimp, served with cocktail sauce and lemon. Minimum five per order
8 Boneless Wings
Lightly breaded, all white meat bonless wings in one sauce
Onion rings
Crispy homemade haystack onion rings
Potato Skins
Melted cheddar, green onion and bacon, served with sour cream
Spin Art Wontons
Our homemade spinach artichoke dip, wrapped into wontons and fried to golden brown, served with sweet chili sauce
Fajita Wrap
Grilled chicken, green and red pepper, onion sauteed with fajita seasoning, lettuce, tomato, feta cheese and jalapeno cilantro sauce
1/2 Order Garlic Parmesan Tally Fries
Half order of garlic parmesan Tally fries
16" Supreme Pizza
Cheese, sausage, mushroom, and onion
Tally Fries
Full order of tally fries
Chips-N-Salsa
Fresh tortilla chips with salsa
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Creamy buffalo chicken dip served with tortilla chips
Mozzarella Sticks
Four hand wrapped wontons, served with marinara sauce
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Mixed greens, grilled shrimp, pineapple salsa, diced tomato, pickled onion, cabbage, carrots and spicy Asian dressing, topped with wontons
HAWAIIAN HAM SANDWICH
Hawiian bun, hot ham lettuce, tomato mayo and your choice of cheese
Roast Beef Unwich
Red bell pepper filled with everything, bagel seasoning cream cheese, roast beef, lettuce, cheddar and avocado.
Ban Mi Portabella Wrap
Asian marinated grilled portabellas, red pepper, jalapeños, mixed greens and cilantro and jalapeno cilantro
16" Crab Rangoon Pizza
Buttery cream cheese sauce, cheese, crab, and green onion drizzled with sweet chili and topped with wonton strips
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Choice of tortilla chips, or celery & carrots
12" Supreme Pizza
Cheese, sausage, mushroom, and onion
Kids 1/2 Grilled Cheese
One half grilled cheese served on texas toast with American cheese. Your choice of Tally fries or applesauce
Kids Chicken Tenders
Three all white meat tenders served with your favorite dipping sauce and choice of Tally fries of applesauce
Kids Mini Corn Dogs
Crispy mini corn dogs served with choice of Tally fries or apple sauce
16" Cheese Pizza
Served the way you like it! Topped with fresh provolone and all our fresh toppings!
Teriyaki Lettuce Wraps
Three lettuce leaves topped with sautéed chicken, bell peppers and onion in a teriyaki sesame glaze and sesame seeds
Poppers
Hand wrapped jalapeno poppers stuffed with cream cheese and wrapped in bacon, served with ranch
1/2 Order Sour Cream Tally Chips
Half order of homemade sour cream Tally Chips
Side Coleslaw
12oz of homemade coleslaw
1/2 Order Tally Fries
Half order of tally fries
Side Caesar Salad
Romaine and croutons tossed in a creamy Caesar dressing
Chips-N-Pico de Gallo
Fresh tortilla chips with homemade pico de gallo
House Salad
Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, with homamde crutons
Veggies & Dip
Carrots, celey, cherry tomato and homemade dill dip
1/2 Order Chips
Half order of homemade chips
Portabella Mushrooms
Served with marinara
People also viewed
About Tally's Tap & Eatery Nutrition Information
Discover the nutritional content of menu items at Tally's Tap & Eatery in Waukesha, WI. Our comprehensive nutrition database provides detailed calorie counts and macronutrient breakdowns (protein, carbohydrates, and fat) for each menu item.
Whether you're tracking macros, counting calories, or simply making healthier dining choices, our nutrition facts help you make informed decisions when eating out. All nutritional values are estimates based on typical ingredients and preparation methods.
How to Use This Information
- • Use the sort buttons to find items by highest/lowest calories, protein, carbs, or fat
- • Compare similar items to make the best choice for your dietary goals
- • Keep in mind that actual values may vary based on preparation and serving size
- • Consider your daily nutritional targets when making selections
Want Nutrition Facts for Any Restaurant?
Enter any restaurant menu URL at macros.menu to get instant nutritional analysis
Analyze Any Menu📚 Cite this page
Copy & paste the citation below:
Macros Menu. "Tally's Tap & Eatery Menu - Nutrition Facts – Macros & Calories." https://macros.menu/tallys-tap-eatery-waukesha-wi. Accessed December 31, 2025.