📱 Download the only app with the macros of over 35,000 restaurant menus.
Settle Down Tavern
Nutrition Facts & Calorie Information
117 S Pinckney St Madison, WI 53703
- PawChicken Dinner! MONDAYS ONLY!
Pasture raised chicken battered & fried and served with mashed potatoes, gravy, slaw, hot honey, and ranch dipping sauce. $18.00 OUT OF STOCK
Classic Chopped Cheese
Inspired by the NYC Original! 100% Locally Farmed Beef, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Settle Sauce, Hero Roll $14.00
LUNCH BASKET! TUESDAY-FRIDAY LUNCH ONLY
Sandwich, fries and a beverage for only $15! Choose a sandwich and a beverage from the available options. Upgrade to ghost fries for $1. $15.00
Want 35,000 menus in your pocket?
Download the MacrosMap app to get the macros for this menu and over 35,000 other restaurant menus.
The Fundamental
We're bringing it back to basics with this one y'all. Quarter pound patty made from 100% locally farmed beef. American cheese. Lettuce. Tomato. Onion. Pickles. Burger Sauce. The fundamentals never tasted better $13.00
Uff Da Dog
Underground Meats Beef Hot Dog, Beef 'n' Bean Chili, House Beer Cheese Sauce! $13.00
Chicken Sando TUESDAY SPECIAL!
Alden Hills Farm (Walworth, WI) pasture-raised chicken. Buttermilk battered and tossed in a spicy buffalo breading. Served with blue cheese aioli, shredded carrots and house made pickles!! $13.00
Meatball Hero WEDNESDAY SPECIAL!
Home-made all beef meatballs fried and topped with home-made marinara sauce and provolone cheese melted onto a toasted hoagie roll. Garnished with fresh parsley. $13.00 OUT OF STOCK
Fish Sandwich FISH FRY FRIDAYS!
Ahhh...welcome to Wisconsin. Settle Down Lager-battered and fried Atlantic Cod, tartar sauce, peppadew relish, pickled jalapeno and lime coleslaw on a pleasant potato bun. (Can be done without the bun!) As John Steinbeck once said, "I remembered not that I had been told Wisconsin is a lovely state, but the telling had not prepared me. It was a magic day." $13.00 OUT OF STOCK
Buffalo Chicken Fries
$13.00
Good Idea (Beef)
Our House Burger! The one you have always been waiting for! Locally raised beef. House pickles. Fried onions. Butterkase cheese from Cedar Grove, WI. Settle Down Sauce. It's a Good Idea to have one - and having two is certainly not a bad idea! "A Good Idea always attracts other Good Ideas. Go Bucky!" -- Thomas Edison Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs, Gluten, Nightshade, Soy, Shellfish (worcestershire in Settle Sauce) $12.00
Jalapeño Hot Rod
Two beef patties smashed with raw onion, topped w/ jalapeño, American cheese, and burger sauce on a potato bun. $12.00
MAGIC Grain Bowl (GF - Veggie)
Oat Groats, Jammy Egg, Crispy Oyster Mushrooms, House Vegan Kimchi, Roasted Broccoli, Puffed Rice Noodles, Sesame Vinaigrette, Whipped Miso Tofu $15.00
Fish Platter FRIDAY FISH FRY!
Big time fish time welcome to Wisconsin. Two delectable pieces of Settle Down Lager-battered and fried Atlantic Cod, tartare sauce, peppadew relish, pickled jalapeno and lime coleslaw ready to make it summer all year long. As Hamlet once said, "This above all - to thine own fish be true." $19.00
Eat out, locked in.
Download the MacrosMap app to get the macros for this menu and over 35,000 other restaurant menus.
Download MacrosMap →Cheese Puppies (gs)
Cheese curds + Hush Puppies = Welcome to Settle Down Tavern Country, population: Meow. These puppies are here to rock your world. Deep-fried and tossed with smoked tomato powder, served with a side of ranch sauce. Dogs and Cats! Living together! Mass hysteria!!! Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs, Nightshade, Soy $11.00
Cuban Sandwich
$13.00
GREEK FREAK (Veggie)
This is our house-made chickpea falafel patty fried to a crispy crust with a moist interior. Pickled tomato, cucumber, onion medley, shredded lettuce, and a garlic yogurt! A slam dunk of vegetarian flavors! P.S. - Vegan w/out the bun Garlic Yogurt P.P.S. - Gluten-free w/out the bun. AND you can opt for a lettuce wrap. Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Gluten, Soy $13.00
French Fries Lg
Big time order of fries whooooooo! Ours are served with ketchup and paprika mayo and free high fives. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade (both in mayo) $9.00
Grilled Cheese
$6.50
Ghost Fries Lg
"Forget about the curveball, Ricky. Give 'em The Heater." FYI - Served with our Blue Cheese Dip. If you would like ketchup please select to add. Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Nightshade. $10.00
Ghost Fries Reg
Our regular French fries tossed in ghost pepper dust - spicy, yes, but not too intense. Think Flamin' Hot Chee-tos. Then think, I'm a champion. FYI - Served with our Blue Cheese Dip. If you would like ketchup please select to add. Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Nightshade $5.50
Chili (Bowl)
$7.00
Pickle Puppies
$5.00
French Fries Reg
French fries. Gluten free! Do they need a description? They don't need a description. They need dipping sauce! Ours are served with ketchup and paprika mayo and free high fives. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade (both in mayo) $4.50
Wedge Salad
Iceberg lettuce, french and blue cheese dressing, blue cheese crumble, thick cut bacon bits, jammy egg, cherry tomato, chives $11.00
Plain Cheeseburger (Beef)
Sometimes peeps don't want pickles, onions and delicious house sauce. So we're making this one easy on the peeps, cuz life is hard, and sometimes we need to enjoy the simple things. A simple, classic Cheeseburger, with nothing else on it. Beef + Cheese + Bun = Fun. $9.50
Uff Da Fries Small
$6.50
Chili (Cup)
$4.00
Betty's Party Mix
Do you like Chex Mix? (I know right? Who doesn't?!) This is a classic homemade family mix, created by Joslyn's Grandma Betty. Crispex, pretzels, peanuts, cheerios, and rye crisps, baked in a buttery mix of worcestershire and other spices. Spoiler alert: Addictive!!! $5.00
Green & Gold Dog
Underground Meats All Beef Hot Dog, House Beer Cheese Sauce, Pickled Jalapeno, Crispy Onion Straws- YUM. $12.00
Kid's Cheeseburger (No seasoning)
Plain smashed beef patty with no salt or pepper on the beef. $9.50
Plain Hot Dog
Underground Meats 100% Beef Hot Dog, Ripper Style! $8.00
Devil Birds
These Devil Birds come to you courtesy of Bryant Family Farms! This jammy egg is served with our fluffy mustard and is topped with crispy paprika panko. $4.00
The Ranch
The one and only Ranch for the cattle wrassler in all of us. Sour cream, buttermilk, eggs, garlic, leeks and seasoning. Giddy-up! Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs $1.00
Mixed Greens
The freshest, healthiest, tastiest mixed greens under the moon. Coming to us from Lovefood Farms, 25 miles from Madison on Pleasant Hill Road. Ours are served with a lemon tarragon vinaigrette and will always just call to say they love you, and will always just call to say how much they care. $5.00
Beer Cheese
House made Beer Cheese Sauce - Made with our House Lager! $3.00
Blue Cheese Dip
We're not saying you're going to tell everyone and their cousins that this is the best blue cheese dip around, but we're not not saying we would be the first to recommend saying that to everyone. And their cousins. Allergies: Dairy $1.00
Pickled Medley
One friendly round of house pickles, served with assorted market vegetables. Always a surprise. Stop. Hammer Time. Allergies: Allium, Nightshade $5.00
Settle Sauce
The house special sauce! A secret-recipe mix of tomato jam, J-1 sauce (our version of A-1), and mayo. Allergies: Allium, Eggs, Nightshades $1.00
Smoked Paprika Mayo
Smoked sweet paprika with homemade mayo and seasoning. As tasty as clapping your hands to a Neil Diamond song. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade $1.00
Burger Sauce
$1.00
Fluffy Mustard
We take mustard made with mustard powder and horseradish and fluff it up with spice for the whole fam damily. Save some for grandpa! Allergies: Dairy, Eggs "Life is a gift, and the moments are always a little better with Settle Down's Fluffy Mustard." -- Julia Child $1.00
Uff Da Fries Lg
$12.00
Calabrian Ghost Pepper Pickle Spears
$5.00
Garlic Dill Pickle Spears
$5.00
People also viewed
About Settle Down Tavern Nutrition Information
Discover the nutritional content of menu items at Settle Down Tavern in Madison, WI. Our comprehensive nutrition database provides detailed calorie counts and macronutrient breakdowns (protein, carbohydrates, and fat) for each menu item.
Whether you're tracking macros, counting calories, or simply making healthier dining choices, our nutrition facts help you make informed decisions when eating out. All nutritional values are estimates based on typical ingredients and preparation methods.
How to Use This Information
- • Use the sort buttons to find items by highest/lowest calories, protein, carbs, or fat
- • Compare similar items to make the best choice for your dietary goals
- • Keep in mind that actual values may vary based on preparation and serving size
- • Consider your daily nutritional targets when making selections
Want Nutrition Facts for Any Restaurant?
Enter any restaurant menu URL at macros.menu to get instant nutritional analysis
Analyze Any Menu📚 Cite this page
Copy & paste the citation below:
Macros Menu. "Settle Down Tavern Menu - Nutrition Facts – Macros & Calories." https://macros.menu/settle-down-tavern-madison-wi. Accessed December 26, 2025.