📱 Download the only app with the macros of over 35,000 restaurant menus.

🍽️
Menu

Castaways On The Lake

Nutrition Facts & Calorie Information

244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580

107items analyzed
"This menu is heavy on fried, breaded, and calorie-dense sandwiches and platters, so overall it’s more suited to bulking than cutting. For cutting pick the Shrimp Cocktail (150 kcal, 20 g protein) or steamed clams — high protein, low calories — and skip rolls/sauces. For bulking choose the Fried Fisherman’s Platter (≈1454 kcal) or a hearty sandwich like the Philly Cheese Steak for an easy way to hit a large calorie target."
Paw from Macros.Menu - Restaurant nutrition analysis expert- Paw
Sort:

Fried Fisherman’s Platter

haddock, shrimp, scallops and clam strips with french fries, cole slaw, tartar or cocktail sauce

⚡️ Calories1454
🥩 Protein68g
🍞 Carbs120g
🧈 Fat78g

Crab Cake Sandwich

with french fries, coleslaw and remoulade sauce

⚡️ Calories1300
🥩 Protein40g
🍞 Carbs120g
🧈 Fat70g

Crab Cake Sandwich

our homemade crab cake served on a brioche bun with french fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce

⚡️ Calories1250
🥩 Protein35g
🍞 Carbs100g
🧈 Fat70g
📱

Want 35,000 menus in your pocket?

Download the MacrosMap app to get the macros for this menu and over 35,000 other restaurant menus.

Download MacrosMap →

Blackened or Fried Grouper Sandwich

with Lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce on a brioche bun with French fries and cole slaw

⚡️ Calories1250
🥩 Protein48g
🍞 Carbs102g
🧈 Fat70g

Baja Fish Tacos

three blackened Mahi Mahi with cabbage, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, cilantro cream sauce inside a soft tortilla with a choice of one side

⚡️ Calories1250
🥩 Protein64g
🍞 Carbs99g
🧈 Fat54g

Philly Cheese Steak

shaved ribeye steak topped with peppers, onions and melted mozzarella, choice of one side

⚡️ Calories1250
🥩 Protein58g
🍞 Carbs106g
🧈 Fat74g

New England Lobster Roll

Lobster blend mixed with mayonnaise, celery and scallions served with french fries and coleslaw

⚡️ Calories1190
🥩 Protein40g
🍞 Carbs100g
🧈 Fat70g

Cattleman’s Chicken Sandwich

with bacon, peppers, onions, barbecue sauce and cheddar cheese on a brioche bun with a choice of one side

⚡️ Calories1180
🥩 Protein79g
🍞 Carbs108g
🧈 Fat49g

Castaway’s Angus Burger

1/2 lb on a brioche bun served with lettuce, tomato, and your choice of one side

⚡️ Calories1154
🥩 Protein59g
🍞 Carbs77g
🧈 Fat71g

Fried Haddock Sandwich

on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, tartar and lemon, french fries and cole slaw

⚡️ Calories1150
🥩 Protein35g
🍞 Carbs111g
🧈 Fat66g

Chicken Wings

10 wings served either sweet and sour or buffalo

⚡️ Calories1100
🥩 Protein70g
🍞 Carbs12g
🧈 Fat82g

Maryland Crab Cakes

with french fries, coleslaw and remoulade sauce

⚡️ Calories1100
🥩 Protein45g
🍞 Carbs95g
🧈 Fat70g

New England Lobster Roll

chunks of lobster blend with mayo, celery, scallions, spices served with french fries and cole slaw

⚡️ Calories1065
🥩 Protein33g
🍞 Carbs86g
🧈 Fat60g
🚀

Eat out, locked in.

Download the MacrosMap app to get the macros for this menu and over 35,000 other restaurant menus.

Download MacrosMap →

Turkey Club Wrap

with bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo in an herb garlic wrap, with a choice of one side

⚡️ Calories1060
🥩 Protein47g
🍞 Carbs83g
🧈 Fat58g

Fried Clam Strip Dinner

⚡️ Calories1050
🥩 Protein35g
🍞 Carbs95g
🧈 Fat55g

Fried Clam Strips

with french fries, cole slaw, lemon and cocktail sauce

⚡️ Calories1035
🥩 Protein30g
🍞 Carbs97g
🧈 Fat54g

Steamed Prince Edward Island Mussels white wine, tomato & garlic broth

⚡️ Calories1000
🥩 Protein109g
🍞 Carbs45g
🧈 Fat47g

New York Strip 14oz

1855 angus strip steak

⚡️ Calories990
🥩 Protein98g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat72g

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

breaded chicken with buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato and blue cheese dressing served in a herb garlic wrap and a choice of one side

⚡️ Calories980
🥩 Protein42g
🍞 Carbs88g
🧈 Fat54g

Chicken Wings(10)

sweet and sour or buffalo

⚡️ Calories980
🥩 Protein60g
🍞 Carbs20g
🧈 Fat70g

New York Strip 14oz

1855 angus strip steak

⚡️ Calories980
🥩 Protein98g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat68g

Fried Shrimp Dinner

⚡️ Calories950
🥩 Protein35g
🍞 Carbs95g
🧈 Fat50g

Snow Crab Legs

1 1/2 lbs with two side choices

⚡️ Calories930
🥩 Protein71g
🍞 Carbs60g
🧈 Fat44g

Alaskan King Crab legs

1 1/4 lbs with two sides

⚡️ Calories920
🥩 Protein112g
🍞 Carbs45g
🧈 Fat29g

Fried Fishermans Platter

fried haddock, shrimp, scallops and clams strips

⚡️ Calories900
🥩 Protein75g
🍞 Carbs45g
🧈 Fat45g

Chicken and Shrimp Jambalaya

with cajun sausage, bell peppers, onions and tomatoes in a hearty-spicy creole sauce over rice

⚡️ Calories880
🥩 Protein60g
🍞 Carbs85g
🧈 Fat38g

New York Strip or Flat Iron Steak with 8oz lobster tail

⚡️ Calories860
🥩 Protein102g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat50g

Prime Pork Porter House Chop

with mushrooms, roasted red peppers finished with a marsala demi glaze

⚡️ Calories860
🥩 Protein76g
🍞 Carbs15g
🧈 Fat50g

Southern Fried Chicken Tenders

with french fries sweet and sour sauce

⚡️ Calories855
🥩 Protein40g
🍞 Carbs90g
🧈 Fat39g

Chicken and Shrimp Jambalaya

chicken, shrimp, cajun sausage, bell peppers and onions cooked in a spicy creole sauce over rice

⚡️ Calories820
🥩 Protein50g
🍞 Carbs85g
🧈 Fat32g

Pasta Rustica

chef blends of vegetables in olive oil, garlic, white wine sauce with parmesan cheese over linguine

⚡️ Calories820
🥩 Protein22g
🍞 Carbs95g
🧈 Fat32g

New York Strip or Flat Iron Steak with 8oz lobster tail

⚡️ Calories820
🥩 Protein102g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat47g

Prime Pork Porter House Chop

with mushrooms, roasted red peppers finished with a marsala demi glaze

⚡️ Calories790
🥩 Protein70g
🍞 Carbs18g
🧈 Fat50g

Pasta Rustica

chef blends of vegetables in olive oil, garlic, white wine sauce with parmesan cheese over linguine

⚡️ Calories780
🥩 Protein26g
🍞 Carbs92g
🧈 Fat30g

New York Strip or Flat Iron Steak with King Crab Legs

⚡️ Calories764
🥩 Protein88g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat46g

Chicken and Shrimp Jambalaya

with cajun sausage, bell peppers, onions and tomatoes in a hearty-spicy creole sauce over rice

⚡️ Calories760
🥩 Protein59g
🍞 Carbs59g
🧈 Fat32g

Seafood Saute

shrimp, scallops and clams sautéed in a lightly seasoned seafood broth over linguine

⚡️ Calories750
🥩 Protein69g
🍞 Carbs76g
🧈 Fat19g

Surf and Turf

New York Strip or Flat Iron Steak with snow crab legs

⚡️ Calories730
🥩 Protein93g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat52g

Maryland Crab Cakes with Remoulade Sauce

Remoulade sauce

⚡️ Calories720
🥩 Protein44g
🍞 Carbs28g
🧈 Fat46g

New York Strip or Flat Iron Steak with King Crab Legs

⚡️ Calories710
🥩 Protein92g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat36g

Flat Iron Steak

10oz certified angus steak

⚡️ Calories710
🥩 Protein74g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat48g

Honey Buffalo Shrimp

sweet and tangy sauce with blue cheese dressing

⚡️ Calories700
🥩 Protein42g
🍞 Carbs46g
🧈 Fat43g

Barbecue Pulled Pork Sandwich

slow roasted pulled pork with savory , sweet and spicy barbecue sauce on a brioche bun

⚡️ Calories700
🥩 Protein30g
🍞 Carbs58g
🧈 Fat32g

Coconut Shrimp with Caribbean Orange Marmalade

⚡️ Calories700
🥩 Protein22g
🍞 Carbs75g
🧈 Fat38g

Coconut Shrimp with mandarin oranges, assorted vegetables, crunchy asian noodles, greens with asian ginger dressing

⚡️ Calories700
🥩 Protein26g
🍞 Carbs72g
🧈 Fat34g

Flat Iron Steak

10oz certified angus steak

⚡️ Calories700
🥩 Protein70g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat50g

New York Strip or Flat Iron with Scallops

⚡️ Calories700
🥩 Protein80g
🍞 Carbs3g
🧈 Fat47g

Maryland Crab Cakes with Remoulade Sauce

Remoulade sauce

⚡️ Calories680
🥩 Protein38g
🍞 Carbs28g
🧈 Fat44g

Coconut Shrimp

served with a Caribbean orange marmalade sauce

⚡️ Calories680
🥩 Protein28g
🍞 Carbs62g
🧈 Fat36g

Chicken French

chicken breast, lightly battered and sautéed in sherry, lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories680
🥩 Protein58g
🍞 Carbs22g
🧈 Fat33g

Chicken French

chicken breast, lightly battered and sautéed in sherry, lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories680
🥩 Protein58g
🍞 Carbs27g
🧈 Fat34g

New York Strip or Flat Iron with Scallops

⚡️ Calories670
🥩 Protein76g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat42g

Vegan Crab Cakes

2 Cakes made with hearts of Palm, Chick Peas, scallions, sweet pepper and spices served with vegan slaw

⚡️ Calories665
🥩 Protein17g
🍞 Carbs65g
🧈 Fat41g

Surf and Turf

New York Strip or Flat Iron Steak with snow crab legs

⚡️ Calories660
🥩 Protein80g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat38g

Coconut Shrimp

with Caribbean orange marmalade sauce

⚡️ Calories650
🥩 Protein24g
🍞 Carbs62g
🧈 Fat38g

Castaway’s Shore Platter

shrimp, scallops and haddock broiled in lemon and butter with a choice of one side

⚡️ Calories650
🥩 Protein60g
🍞 Carbs45g
🧈 Fat28g

Grilled Salmon with mandarin oranges, assorted vegetables, crunchy asian noodles and greens with asian ginger dressing

⚡️ Calories650
🥩 Protein42g
🍞 Carbs58g
🧈 Fat32g

Castaway’s Fish Fry

10-12 oz haddock filet

⚡️ Calories630
🥩 Protein64g
🍞 Carbs14g
🧈 Fat26g

Snow Crab Legs

1 1/2 lbs with two side choices

⚡️ Calories628
🥩 Protein64g
🍞 Carbs50g
🧈 Fat20g

Chicken Asiago

chicken breast sautéed with mushrooms, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives, marsala wine and asiago cheese

⚡️ Calories620
🥩 Protein61g
🍞 Carbs9g
🧈 Fat35g

Chicken Asiago

chicken breast sautéed with mushrooms, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives, marsala wine and asiago cheese

⚡️ Calories610
🥩 Protein62g
🍞 Carbs12g
🧈 Fat32g

Coconut Crusted Grouper

with a mango and pineapple salsa

⚡️ Calories590
🥩 Protein41g
🍞 Carbs33g
🧈 Fat35g

Alaskan King Crab legs

1 1/4 lbs with two sides

⚡️ Calories586
🥩 Protein44g
🍞 Carbs31g
🧈 Fat34g

Caribbean Lobster Tails

8oz lobster tails either single or twin with two sides choices

⚡️ Calories570
🥩 Protein48g
🍞 Carbs45g
🧈 Fat18g

Basket of Artisan Dinner Rolls

⚡️ Calories560
🥩 Protein16g
🍞 Carbs88g
🧈 Fat14g

Broiled or Fried Haddock

broiled in lemon butter or fried with your choice of a side

⚡️ Calories550
🥩 Protein35g
🍞 Carbs30g
🧈 Fat30g

Key West Pineapple Shrimp Skewers

over rice

⚡️ Calories550
🥩 Protein28g
🍞 Carbs70g
🧈 Fat15g

Castaway’s Shore Platter

shrimp, scallops, haddock broiled in lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories540
🥩 Protein80g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat25g

Coconut Shrimp

⚡️ Calories520
🥩 Protein20g
🍞 Carbs35g
🧈 Fat32g

Honey Buffalo Shrimp

⚡️ Calories520
🥩 Protein30g
🍞 Carbs38g
🧈 Fat28g

Fried Calamari with marinara for dipping

⚡️ Calories520
🥩 Protein25g
🍞 Carbs42g
🧈 Fat28g

Vegan Crab Cakes

2 Cakes made with hearts of Palm, Chick Peas, scallions, sweet pepper and spices served with vegan slaw

⚡️ Calories520
🥩 Protein14g
🍞 Carbs56g
🧈 Fat24g

Castaway’s Shore Platter

shrimp, scallops and haddock broiled in lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories490
🥩 Protein90g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat15g

Stuffed Haddock

with a scallop and shrimp seafood stuffing

⚡️ Calories490
🥩 Protein62g
🍞 Carbs22g
🧈 Fat16g

Fried Calamari

with marinara sauce for dipping

⚡️ Calories480
🥩 Protein26g
🍞 Carbs34g
🧈 Fat28g

Baked French Onion

our classic recipe

⚡️ Calories480
🥩 Protein20g
🍞 Carbs40g
🧈 Fat24g

Basket of Artisan Dinner Rolls

⚡️ Calories480
🥩 Protein12g
🍞 Carbs80g
🧈 Fat12g

Castaway’s Shore Platter

shrimp, scallops, haddock broiled in lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories480
🥩 Protein80g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat16g

Castaway’s Shore Platter

shrimp, scallops, haddock broiled in lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories472
🥩 Protein56g
🍞 Carbs3g
🧈 Fat26g

Fried Zucchini Sticks

with marinara for dipping

⚡️ Calories470
🥩 Protein11g
🍞 Carbs42g
🧈 Fat31g

Baked French Onion

our classic recipe

⚡️ Calories460
🥩 Protein20g
🍞 Carbs35g
🧈 Fat26g

Mediterranean Haddock

with Artichokes, kalamata olives, red onion, fresh tomato, feta cheese in a white wine lemon butter sauce

⚡️ Calories460
🥩 Protein45g
🍞 Carbs22g
🧈 Fat25g

Caribbean Lobster Tails

8oz lobster tails either single or twin with two sides choices

⚡️ Calories460
🥩 Protein52g
🍞 Carbs46g
🧈 Fat13g

Chicken Salad Grilled or Blackened

⚡️ Calories450
🥩 Protein44g
🍞 Carbs12g
🧈 Fat24g

Baked Salmon

with a cucumber dill sauce

⚡️ Calories400
🥩 Protein41g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat24g

Grilled Salmon

⚡️ Calories367
🥩 Protein39g
🍞 Carbs0g
🧈 Fat22g

Lobster Bisque

house specialty

⚡️ Calories340
🥩 Protein18g
🍞 Carbs14g
🧈 Fat22g

Fried Zucchini with marinara for dipping

⚡️ Calories330
🥩 Protein7g
🍞 Carbs34g
🧈 Fat20g

Artichoke French

with a sherry, lemon and butter sauce

⚡️ Calories320
🥩 Protein4g
🍞 Carbs12g
🧈 Fat24g

Castaway’s House Salad

⚡️ Calories310
🥩 Protein6g
🍞 Carbs28g
🧈 Fat18g

Lobster Bisque

Cup 9, Bowl 12

⚡️ Calories300
🥩 Protein15g
🍞 Carbs12g
🧈 Fat20g

Bruschetta Bread

tomato, garlic, olive oil, mozzarella

⚡️ Calories300
🥩 Protein9g
🍞 Carbs18g
🧈 Fat21g

Broiled Sea Scallops

natural, dry sea scallops broiled in lemon and butter

⚡️ Calories290
🥩 Protein34g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat14g

Stuffed Mushrooms with scallops and shrimp seafood stuffing

⚡️ Calories280
🥩 Protein24g
🍞 Carbs22g
🧈 Fat8g

Chicken Grilled or Blackened

with assorted fresh vegetables and greens

⚡️ Calories280
🥩 Protein38g
🍞 Carbs12g
🧈 Fat9g

Castaway’s House Salad

⚡️ Calories280
🥩 Protein7g
🍞 Carbs22g
🧈 Fat18g

Bruschetta Bread

tomato, garlic, olive oil and mozzarella

⚡️ Calories270
🥩 Protein10g
🍞 Carbs30g
🧈 Fat12g

Fried Scallop Dinner

dry, natural sea scallops

⚡️ Calories270
🥩 Protein26g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat16g

Steamed Prince Edward Island Mussels

with a white wine, tomato and garlic broth

⚡️ Calories230
🥩 Protein28g
🍞 Carbs10g
🧈 Fat8g

Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms

with a scallop and shrimp stuffing

⚡️ Calories200
🥩 Protein18g
🍞 Carbs8g
🧈 Fat10g

Artichokes French with sherry, lemon, butter

⚡️ Calories190
🥩 Protein4g
🍞 Carbs15g
🧈 Fat12g

Shrimp Cocktail

⚡️ Calories150
🥩 Protein20g
🍞 Carbs17g
🧈 Fat1g

Shrimp Cocktail

⚡️ Calories150
🥩 Protein20g
🍞 Carbs17g
🧈 Fat1g

Salad dressings Castaway’s House Italian, Creamy Blue Cheese, Ranch, Thousand Island and Poppyseed. Creamy Blue and Crumbly Blue are an additional $2.75

⚡️ Calories150
🥩 Protein1g
🍞 Carbs5g
🧈 Fat13g

Salad dressings Castaway’s House Italian, Creamy Blue Cheese, Ranch, Thousand Island and Poppyseed. Creamy Blue and Crumbly Blue are an additional $2.75

⚡️ Calories150
🥩 Protein1g
🍞 Carbs8g
🧈 Fat12g

Steamed Clams one dozen

⚡️ Calories140
🥩 Protein24g
🍞 Carbs7g
🧈 Fat2g

Steamed Clams

one dozen

⚡️ Calories70
🥩 Protein12g
🍞 Carbs2g
🧈 Fat1g

People also viewed

About Castaways On The Lake Nutrition Information

Discover the nutritional content of menu items at Castaways On The Lake in Webster, NY. Our comprehensive nutrition database provides detailed calorie counts and macronutrient breakdowns (protein, carbohydrates, and fat) for each menu item.

Whether you're tracking macros, counting calories, or simply making healthier dining choices, our nutrition facts help you make informed decisions when eating out. All nutritional values are estimates based on typical ingredients and preparation methods.

How to Use This Information

  • • Use the sort buttons to find items by highest/lowest calories, protein, carbs, or fat
  • • Compare similar items to make the best choice for your dietary goals
  • • Keep in mind that actual values may vary based on preparation and serving size
  • • Consider your daily nutritional targets when making selections

Want Nutrition Facts for Any Restaurant?

Enter any restaurant menu URL at macros.menu to get instant nutritional analysis

Analyze Any Menu

📚 Cite this page

Copy & paste the citation below:

Macros Menu. "Castaways On The Lake Menu - Nutrition Facts – Macros & Calories." https://macros.menu/castaways-on-the-lake-webster-ny. Accessed December 31, 2025.
Macronutrient estimates are generated by AI. This tool is a lighthouse not a source of truth - use it to get a general idea of the macronutrient content of a menu. Privacy Policy